“Do you wear earrings darling?” She asks as she continues to clean up the kitchen bench she’s been pottering away at for the past hour. I don’t know exactly what she’s been doing, but I’m finding myself getting more frustrated the longer she takes. We were meant to leave for Cairns as soon as we woke up, but three hours later, we’re still nowhere close to leaving.
“No, I don’t” I respond, hoping that’s the end of the conversation.
“Oh why not darling?”
She looks over the kitchen counter at me. I try to find the words to say as my heart takes a leap.
“I just … don’t like them…” I respond with, once again hoping that’s the end of our conversation and we can get on the road to Cairns so we can find the place she wants her ashes scattered.
She looks at me confused, as her pearl drop earrings shimmer in the light.
“Do you have your ears pierced, darling?”
“Stop with the fucking darling!” I want to scream, I want to tell her to hurry the fuck up and most importantly I want to tell her “yes they are fucking pierced because you held me down and poked a needle in them when I was 8 years old!” The trauma of the memory is the sole reason I don’t wear earrings everyday and is the same reason why the holes in my ears never close over, and haven’t since that night.
It’s just one of the several truths I have to keep from her at this point in her life. It’s not worth telling her a story either she can’t remember or chooses specifically to ignore. Part of me, in this moment, wonders if it’s a test. If she remembers exactly what she did.
See it was one of those rare years she celebrated my birthday, and her gift to me, was getting my ears pierced at the local shopping centre. I screamed and cried I didn’t want it done, my brothers didn’t have pierced ears so why did I have to?
“You’re a girl” was the response, and I was dragged into the shop, the circulation in my arm severely restricted by her grip.
Just like every other birthday, I managed to ruin it for her. Once it was by riding my bike in a dress and tearing the hem on it. This year, it was by forgetting… purposefully, to put the studs in my ears and allowing them to close over in a matter of days.
When she found out, she told me I was an ungrateful cunt, before boiling the kettle, forcing me down on the table or floor or some other hard surface, her knee jabbed into my back, and pushing a needle through my ear. I screamed and cried and sobbed and begged for it to stop. When it finally did, she told me it was my fault. If I didn’t fuck it up the first time, I wouldn’t have had to experience this now. I sobbed and she asked,
“What do you say now?”
“Thank you” I whimpered before heading to bed at 3am in the morning.
Pushing that memory out of my mind, I look for an escape.
I go to the bathroom to avoid the conversation any longer, the memories and try to focus on my breathing. I’ve been using phenergen again to help me sleep, but found that it didn’t help much last night at all. In between feeling alone and lost and trying to care for my dying abuser, I remembered a nightmare that has plagued me for the last six months.
I am in North Queensland, over 3000kms from home in Melbourne, and try as I might I can never get back to Melbourne. It’s always different people and combinations of events that stop me, but months roll by and I lose my job and I get stuck up here. Now, my nightmare is real. She wants me to relocate and work from home up here. Pressure from every single doctor, nurse, specialist and even neighbour makes me feel like a horrible daughter for not wanting to. I want to scream on a daily basis, I want to tell each and every person that she doesn’t deserve the time, effort and energy i’m putting into her at present let alone any further.
But I can’t. Because regardless of everything, and all the years of therapy, I’m still that little girl wishing for her mothers approval and doing anything to get it. How fucking pathetic.
As I make my way back to the kitchen, having calmed myself down enough to not have a full blown panic attack, I notice she’s struggling with something.
She asks,
“Darling, can you help me with this?” And points to the new hole she is trying to poke into her watch.
At this point in time, it definitely feels like she remembers. Like she’s testing me, taunting me and hoping I give her a reason to exclude me from the inheritance.
I smile and say, “of course”.
I pick up the sharp needle she’s using, and push it through with ease, just as she did all those years ago to my ear lobes. Cow leather isn’t that different to human flesh, but here lies the reason I believe my mother is “different”: she doesn’t have the strength anymore to be abusive.
My whole life, she held incredible power over me, even when I didn’t speak to her for close to twenty years, she still managed to plague my mind. Now, seeing her like this, frail and losing strength day by day, I realise I finally have the power I always wish I had over her.
———
It’s about 10:45am by the time we finally hit the road. I’m frustrated but I do my best to hide it. Her complete lack of time awareness has always grated me. To this day, I take people being late as an insult – because part of me feels like something must have been much more important than keeping their word to me. I know sometimes it’s unavoidable, sometimes shit happens, and sure, I’ll be understanding and forgiving but part of me goes back to the little girl waiting for her mum to turn up, four hours after school finished. Wondering if today is the day she’s finally decided to leave and never return.
I’ve often wondered if this trait continued after she lost custody of us. She started working again not long after, and was able to hold down steady employment for 22 years in the cleaning industry. Her lack of tardiness is undesirable in social settings, let alone settings where people are expected to be on time for completion of a job they are being paid for. The irony isn’t lost on me that the reason she is always late to everything is because she is too busy cleaning the house with an obsessive compulsion, and yet the only ever time she was probably on time in her life, was for her cleaning job.
I’m trying my hardest to not have a panic attack the entire 4 hour drive. She keeps asking questions for which I only have one line sentence responses.
“So, darling, do you like your job?”
“Not really”
“Why not darling?”
“Because it’s banking, it’s hard to be passionate about numbers”
She laughs, struggles to breathe and manages to get out,
“And you are so bad with numbers”.
She’s not wrong. She’s noticed it after the nights of scrabble and me struggling to add up the scores. Sure, I have the dyslexia version of incoherence with numbers as dyslexics have with words, but more so, I am constantly on edge around her, feeling her make quiet judgment as I try to combine scores.
“I decided not to bring a book because I thought we could talk the whole way” she manages to say. Fuck. I don’t know what she wants to talk about, what more we have to say to each other. The only thing we seem to be able to talk about in depth, are the flaws of my siblings or father. I ponder the fact that it’s the only thing that animates her and keeps her interested, and yet feel so fucking dirty every time it’s brought up. I feel like a KGB agent, reporting back to mother Russia after being a sleeper agent in the US for years. Except my loyalty doesn’t lie with Russia. It doesn’t necessarily lie with the US either, but once again I’m being manipulated into playing her games.
“So, has Fred* said anything?”
I’m torn between telling her how badly we’ve fallen out over the years, or lying. I opt for the former.
“Actually he finally messaged me to ask me if I needed help”
She takes a moment and asks,
“Help for what?” As if the gargling, constant struggle to breathe and reliance on a designated driver and translator are not at all a hindrance to a normal human.
“With this situation.”
She nods her head and looks forward,
“And what did you say darling?”
I give it all to her. Fred is my older brother by a bit under 2 years. Our relationship has been a rollercoaster over the years, but we had a few really good years in my early to mid twenties. We spoke two or three times a week on the phone, could spend hours getting drunk and discussing the politics and philosophies of the world. He was my best friend for a while and it was one of the most meaningful relationships in my entire life thus far. by the time he walked me down the aisle at my first wedding, we were no longer as close as I had hoped. Things started fracturing around the same time I got sober and started putting boundaries up. I stopped being everyone’s “yes” girl, and started actually saying “no” in an effort to stop people from abusing the fact that I was an avid people pleaser with an insatiable desire to prove my worth by going above and beyond, no matter the cost or time required.
“Well, I thanked him. And told him mainly I needed help for my mental health, as I’m exhausted most days and it’s a lot to deal with sometimes.”
She says nothing.
“And he said he couldn’t be there for me mentally, and had no intention of getting involved or helping beyond maybe making appointments for you.”
She scoffs
“That’d be bloody right, just like your father. Lazy and useless.”
I’m not sure what to say to this, but continue my vent, trying carefully to exclude my brother from the narrative, but at this point I’ve given her weaponised words to use against an old target and it comes so naturally to her.
The truth is, my older brother was the last of my siblings to offer help or assistance. And yet when he offered it, it came with a paragraph of messages about why he actually can’t help, and that we’re clearly different people and unable to see eye to eye.
It hit me like a tonne of bricks. I thought maybe, just maybe, we could work together through this. Instead I’m taken back to our childhood. Back to when our father got custody of us and Fred spent the majority of his time in his bedroom downstairs, isolating himself and playing his pc. Meanwhile, I was upstairs, bathing, changing nappies, preparing meals. My father was overwhelmed with the stress of having 5 kids thrust on to him, and retracted to his couch or his computer after work and serving us one of four staple dinners. (Frozen pie reheated with mash and veggies, pizza, sausages too burnt to be considered edible with mash and veggies or “look after yourself tonight” which meant a sandwich or two minute noodles)
I taught my youngest brother, Sydney*, how to write, read and ride a bike. I organised sports for him after school. I read books to him and my younger sister Trina, for all intents and purposes I took on the role of a parent. Not because I wanted to, but because someone had to. I developed major PTSD from this period of my life, because I was so alone, I wanted a parent who was capable of caring for me and instead, I had to be the parent and care for others.
Fred went through quite a violent phase during this time. One my mother brought up in an earlier conversation. She laughed as she recalled Fred almost breaking our dads arm and wanting to kill him with poison. The amount of times I was at the receiving end of his pent up rage – him calling me a liar and reinforcing years of verbal and emotional abuse he had overhead from our mother, it led me to resenting him, almost hating him at times.
Hate is a strong word. I didn’t hate him. I hated my mother because I knew my brother wasn’t a bad person, but I knew that he was so heavily influenced by her still that it was going to take a long time to break him free of those patterns of thoughts. He placed our mother on this pedestal, she was incapable of being a horrible monster and instead was the victim of our lazy wanker of a fathers’ plot to steal us away from her and turn us against her. Speaking out against her, doing anything that would jeopardise her ability to see him, was sacrilege.
It’s a pattern I’ve noticed in the years since. Fred has a tendency of placing people on pedestals, living and breathing their beliefs and thoughts and then losing his temper or patience if you question his true feelings. It’s led to relationships he’s stayed in for long after he’s become unhappy and unfulfilled. It’s led to him squashing his beliefs and desires in life down and instead taking on board others, which would cause most people to suffer with severe anxiety from the constant cognitive dissonance, but for him it’s such a normal pattern of behaviour that it’s now entirely pointless to even try to question if he’s happy with the decisions “he’s” making.
I guess at some point, you just have to accept that people will make decisions and choices you might not understand, but you have to support them regardless. Something I suck at.
“So why would he offer to help and then not offer to help?” She tsks her tongue and shakes her head.
Fuck. Now I’ve said too much. I don’t know how to back peddle, so ask myself her question.
“I think, maybe, he just lacks empathy.”
This statement, is something that has just occurred to me. While I was busy raising my younger brother and sister, Fred couldn’t find the empathy in those moment to push past his own emotions and focus on what the task at hand was. I, in turn, developed an overbearing sense of needing to help people and place myself in situations where I would take control because I learned no one else would.
This lack of empathy I sense from him, is something that inherently comes from both of our parents. I think it’s a coping mechanism. Dad didn’t know how to be there for us, because he was too busy trying to survive each day with this enormous task he’d taken on. He needed to be fixed first before he could fix anyone else. On the other hand, our mother just straight up lacked any empathy, unless it was for poor helpless animals. And in turn, I potentially had stripped my brother and younger sister of it because I did everything in my power to fix situations, rather than trusting they would find a solution.
As we’re driving through the mist covered banana fields, rain slowly hitting our windshield I’m reminded of my brothers car accident. At that point in time, I was so worried we would lose him, or he would have permanent brain damage. He was nearly 19 and I was 17 in my last year of high school. I had a nightmare about him and a cliff and awoke at 4am to my stepmother shaking me , telling me dad has rushed to the hospital because Fred has had a car accident.
“I spent so many hours by his bedside, listening to his story over and over again about the hospital bed being the same as the one NASA uses.” I laugh at the memory. Each time he awoke, he told the story and was so impressed by the fact that he was essentially sleeping in an astronauts bed.
“And did he come to the hospital when you lost your baby last year?” She asks, already knowing the answer, but needing to further fuel the fire now simmering inside.
It hits me that he’s never been there for me in hospital. That he never visited all those times I tried to kill myself, all the days spent in the mental health wards and most recently the two times in the past two years I lost both my babies and fallopian tubes. In each instance, I’d be lucky to get a text message from him. In fact, his response to any trauma in my life has been lacking. I lost my soul dog, and I didn’t get a single message from him. I lost two babies, nothing. I lost my marriage and he kind of reached out, but as if I was nothing more than a stranger from work. I realise that perhaps, my feeling of losing my best friend in him, was entirely one sided.
“Do you remember the time I picked you up from Walkerston and those horrid Russo brothers were bullying you? Fred was there and he did nothing, absolutely useless he was. What a coward.”
She tuts again and takes a swig of black coffee from her flask. I turn up the music, hoping she assumes it’s just to cover the guttural unappeasing noises coming from her as she struggles to swallow. In reality, I’m trying to process the epitome I’ve just had.
To him, I wasn’t a best friend or little sister. I was just a person who was sometimes fun to drink with and talk to. Then I stopped drinking and I guess there became little fun we could have together. Alcohol was a cornerstone of our relationship, he was there the first time I got drunk. Some of our best memories were at friends places nestled in between cane paddocks, drinking copious amounts of alcohol and laughing at my expense.
When I gave up alcohol, I think it might have made him consider his relationship with alcohol. Because if I had an issue with drinking, then he definitely did. If my drinking was caused by the trauma our mother caused, then his most likely was to. And if I was only fun when I was drinking, then perhaps he thought he was also only fun while drinking too.
——-
The rest of the drive is uneventful. We arrive in Cairns and promptly find the cheapest accomodation possible. She pays and asks that we sleep in separate beds. Part of me is offended, after all I know plenty of women who sleep in the same bed as their mum when travelling but at the same time I’m grateful because sleeping in the same bed as her would unleash a whole new set of traumatic memories that I’m not sure I’m ready to relive yet.
After spending the afternoon scouring spots for her ashes to be thrown, we make our way back to a little leagues club for a late dinner. The drive back has us discussing her desire to come back here with my younger brother, Michael* and his partner. I suggest perhaps doing it for her birthday in a few weeks time, after all it will be Easter on her birthday which allows a good 4 days to explore the region she wants to be put to rest in.
“That’s a wonderful idea darling” she beams at the suggestion, as we make our way into the tavern.
Beside our table is a large group of people and two giant balloons marked “60”. As they bring out the cake and sing happy birthday, mum and I watch on. The woman, embarrassed by the attention, has a wonderful array of friends from varying ethnicities and age groups. I understand she is embarrassed by the attention suddenly shining on her, but I can’t help but smile – what an incredible person she must be to have that many people still in her life at that age, I think to myself.
Then it dawns on me. My mother won’t ever reach that age. In fact, her 59th birthday in three weeks time will be her last. I look at her and she seems to be thinking the same thing as she looks on at the party, not saying a word, a fake smile on her face and eyes that convey a deeply sad look of envy.
I guess her mortality should have been the moment she tried to apologise for the monster she was. To make amends and give that final gift of gratitude to her children. But it’s not. She will never acknowledge her children not seeing her, all six of them, for many years, is anything but an utter display of cruel malicious abandonment. Abandonment that she recently confided in me, led to alcoholism.